
CLMP volunteers collect water transparency data
using an 8-inch, circular, all-white metal plate
attached to a calibrated rope. This tool is
called a Secchi disk. About once a week during
the summer, volunteers boat to a designated spot
on their lakes to collect transparency readings.
The volunteer lowers the disk into the water
until it is no longer visible and notes that
depth from the markings on the rope. The disk is
then lowered a little further and then raised
back up until it is just visible. This second
depth reading is averaged with the first, and
the final number is recorded on a data sheet. At
the end of summer, volunteers send their data
sheets to the MPCA to be compiled with other
water-quality data.
Water transparency is a
quick and easy measurement that tells scientists
a lot about a lake's water quality. First it
indicates the amount of light penetration into a
lake. Second, Secchi transparency provides an
indirect measure of the amount of suspended
material in the water, which in many cases is an
indication of the amount of algae in the water.
Long-term transparency monitoring by CLMP
volunteers helps scientists detect signs of
degradation to a lake. Generally, the sooner
water-quality problems are detected, the easier
and less expensive it is to restore the lake to
its previous state.
Example of an Oligotrophic lake.
Example of an Hypereutrophic lake.

Carlson Trophic
Status
Carlson’s
Trophic State Index (TSI) is a common means
for characterizing a lake’s
trophic state (overall health) and
associating Secchi, chlorophyll-a,
and phosphorus measurements.
The term “trophic
status” refers to the level of productivity in a
lake as measured by phosphorous content, algae
abundance, and depth of light penetration.
Carlson’s Trophic
State Index is one means available to examine the
relationship between total phosphorus, chlorophyll-a,
and Secchi disk readings in a lake and its overall
productivity.
Individual TSI values can be calculated from
the following equations:
Total
phosphorus TSI (TSIP) = 14.42*[ln(TP
average)]
+ 4.15
Chlorophyll-a
TSI (TSIC) = 9.81*[ln(Chlorophyll-a
average)]
+ 30.6
Secchi
disk TSI (TSIS) = 60 -
(14.41*[ln(Secchi
average)])
Total phosphorus and
chlorophyll-a are measured in micrograms per liter
and Secchi disk transparency is measured in meters
(3.281 feet per meter). The ln function in these
equations is the "natural log" which is different
than the "log" function. The TSI scale ranges from 0
(ultra-oligotrophic) to 100 (hypereutrophic). High
and/or increasing trophic status values indicate
eutrophic conditions (higher productivity).
Carlson’s
Trophic
State
Index
R.E. Carlson
TSI < 30
Classical Oligotrophy:
Clear water, oxygen throughout the year in
the hypolimnion,
salmonid fisheries in
deep lakes.
TSI 30
- 40
Deeper lakes still exhibit classical
oligotrophy, but some
shallower lakes will become anoxic in the
hypolimnion during the
summer.
TSI 40
- 50
Water moderately clear, but increasing probability
of anoxia in hypolimnion
during summer.
TSI 50
- 60
Lower boundary of classical
eutrophy:
Decreased transparency, anoxic
hypolimnia during the
summer, macrophyte
problems evident, warm-water fisheries only.
TSI 60
- 70
Dominance of blue-green algae, algal
scums probable,
extensive macrophyte
problems.
TSI 70
- 80
Heavy algal blooms possible throughout the summer,
dense macrophyte
beds, but
extent limited by light penetration. Often would be classified as
hypereutrophic.
TSI > 80
Algal scums, summer fish
kills, few macrophytes,
dominance of rough fish.